Both of these phrases mean "it is" or "this is," so what is the difference between them? When should one be used over the other?
- Anybody can ask a question
- Anybody can answer
- The best answers are voted up and rise to the top
Il est can either be designating someone (therefore meaning “he is”, rather than “it is”, as is c'est), or on the contrary be a construct in which there is no subject (as in Il est tard, or Il est possible que …, etc.).
In the latter cases, you can distinguish the cases when c'est refers to a neutral subject (“it is”, really ; e.g. c'est tard will mean “this event is late”) from the cases when there really is no subject (“it rains”).
I can't think of any case where “this is” would be the translation of “il est” ; maybe your question is all about “ça / il” being the translation of “it / he”.
When this applies to a person (masculine), 'il est' is the only option.
When this applies to a concept / idea where there can be a confusion with a person, 'c'est ' is the correct choice: 'c'est malheureux' and 'il est malheureux' do have different meanings, and can lead to confusion, when one is talking\writing about a person.
Out of this ambiguitous situation, 'c'est' and 'il est' belong to different levels of language: 'c'est' is perceived as more popular, and does not require further information. 'il est' is perceived as more sophisticated, and might need some further information: