9

As far as I know, both words mean the same thing in English — “start”. Is there any difference in the meaning or in the usage of the two verbs?

  • 3
    You've got several verbs in English to express the idea of a beginning as well: start, begin, commence. They all have their own specific uses too, unfortunately it seems the semantics don't overlap the same way as in French. – didierc Dec 4 '14 at 15:02
5

Démarrer implies some initial impulse or effort. Etymologically it comes from désamarrer (i.e. “undock” a boat, which is not necessarily a trivial matter). An extended figurative use slowly emerged, competing with the use of commencer in the beginning of the 20th century, but commencer is still far more common.

One can often substitute one for the other, but a slight nuance exists. In the following sentence:

Il a démarré sa carrière à la télévision.

the TV appears more relevant to the development of this person's career than in:

Il a commencé sa carrière à la télévision.

3

Dans un registre familier, ils sont PRESQUE interchangeables (on évitera par exemple de dire "commencer le moteur").

Il n'y a malheureusement pas de règles précises.

http://www.cce.umontreal.ca/observations/debuter.htm

1

Je traduirais plutôt :

Démarrer -> to kick off
Commencer -> to begin

  • Merci beaucoup. But can I use the two interchangeably? – user3182445 Nov 29 '14 at 11:22
  • @user3182445: Not really, it depends on context. You can translate both by start but it's too vague in most cases. – Toto Nov 29 '14 at 11:31
1

Démarrer est lié à la notion de nouveauté, d'effort. Commencer est plutôt lié à l’immédiateté de l'action.

0

As in so many cases in French, there's no specific rule but if you're French, you know, if you're not French, you'll never know. They learn it through osmosis I think. The best I can get is demarrer implies some effort whereas commence is something which just kind of happens. So starting cars, chainsaws, conversation tends to be demarrer but if you look over your shoulder and see something has already started, it's commencer. Best I can do but no one is going to roast you for mixing them up.

New contributor
Steve Marsh is a new contributor to this site. Take care in asking for clarification, commenting, and answering. Check out our Code of Conduct.
  • Selon quelles sources ? – Toto yesterday
  • 1
    Welcome to FL. Please read the Help pages and more specifically how to answer questions. Saying "As in so many cases in French, there's no specific rule" or "if you're not French, you'll never know" are general statements (and can be controversial) and would need to be backed by specific examples. When you write in French do not forget to accentuate the letters that need to be accentuated. – Laure SO - Écoute-nous yesterday

Your Answer

By clicking “Post Your Answer”, you agree to our terms of service, privacy policy and cookie policy

Not the answer you're looking for? Browse other questions tagged or ask your own question.