9

What is the best way to self-effacingly say:

I speak french with a bad accent.

Would it be:

Je parle français avec un mauvais accent anglais.

The difficulty I'm having is in distinguishing between an English accent (like the country with the crumpets and roast beef) and an English-language accent (my accent is North American).

Would it be appropriate / well-understood to say:

Je parle français avec un mauvais accent anglophone.

  • 1
    Any way there is use of "bad" to qualify an accent in French. You usually talk about a "strong" one (or a "weak"). – Pierre Watelet Jan 28 '16 at 8:17
  • All what you say will be understood, but I would simply say "j'ai un mauvais accent en anglais" instead. – Simon Mourier Jan 29 '16 at 7:38
9

You normally don't state you speak with an accent anglophone as it is not the accent which is anglophone but you.

The accent is English so you would say:

Je parle avec l'accent anglais (or américain if you want to tell where you come from.)

Je parle français avec l'accent anglais.

To translate "bad accent", you'll use fort in French:

Je parle français avec un fort accent anglais.

If you really want to use anglophone, you might say:

Je parle français avec l'accent d'un anglophone.

but that seems a little odd.

Actually, you shouldn't worry about whether your accent is British English or American English. While there is with no doubt a difference when someone speaks English with either of these, this difference is much less noticeable when they speak French. Most native French people wouldn't tell the difference.

Anyway, if you are talking to native French people, that might not be worth telling you have an accent in the first place as the fact will be obvious after very few words.

  • Au TLFi, dans le sens de ce qu'on propose, ds. la section des syntagmes fréquents etc. Chez Larousse aussi intéressant. – user3177 Jan 24 '16 at 12:38
6

En français, on dit rarement qu'on utilise un mauvais accent (qu'est-ce que c'est d'ailleurs ?)

Version la plus courante:

Je parle français avec un accent (sous-entendu: accent étranger).

Si l'on veut préciser:

Je parle français avec un accent anglais (ou anglophone).

  • 1
    L'adjectif « anglophone » peut s'appliquer à une personne ou une région mais pas à un accent. – Toto Jan 24 '16 at 11:15
  • @Toto , disons que accent anglophone = accent d'une personne qui parle anglais. Cela s'emploie pour un américain, ou une personne d'origine incertaine. – guillaume girod-vitouchkina Jan 24 '16 at 11:53
  • Je n'ai jamais entendu ce raccourci. Un accent n'est ni une personne s'exprimant dans la langue anglaise, ni une région de langue anglaise. Ce sont les seules définitions d'anglophone. – jlliagre Jan 24 '16 at 13:25
  • 1
    Et "je parle français avec un (mauvais/sale) accent d'anglophone"? – Vérace Jan 24 '16 at 17:06
1

Vu que tu parles déjà français en parlant de ton accent, pas besoin de dire que tu parles français et l'origine de l'accent est soit, peut importante, soit évidente, tu n'as donc pas besoin de préciser d'où viens ton accent. Pour moi la phrase correcte serait donc :

"J'ai un gros accent" ou "Je parle avec un mauvais accent".

0

I'm not sure what your question is but to fit your specific problem, you could ask:

Je parle français avec l'accent américain ?
Est-ce que vous entendez que je suis américain(e) quand je parle français ?

0

It seems that you’re already prepared to modestly criticize yourself (or at least willing to call attention to your [bad/strong] accent & that of your typical compatriots), so why not spice up your declaration & take it to another, full-blown, self-deprecating level (As with self-effacement, I find self-deprecation, in moderation, to be endearing … regardless, it’s a whole lot better than coming across as self-aggrandizing and arrogant, but I digress).

Besides, your knowledge and use of the following idiomatic "insults" (directed only at yourself, of course) might possibly impress (or perhaps 'disgust'?) your French audience to the point where the "issue," probably self-perceived, of your [again, probably self-perceived/self-exaggerated] "bad" accent will no longer be of any concern.

Since yours is a North American accent, you could paraphrase an idiomatic expression as follows:

Je parle français comme une vache américaine/canadienne.

Although the unparaphrased/unedited version of this expression is, in my opinion based on its origins, insulting to Spanish Basques, to Spanish migrant workers, and/or even to Spaniards in general (not to mention all the unfairly maligned Spanish cows), the paraphrased version suggested above would probably be viewed primarily as a self-inflicted poke at yourself, but please be mindful that it could also be taken as a gratuitous slam of your country's entire cow population.

(please note, however, that by using this phrase, especially the original/unedited version, you’d probably be seen as criticizing your over-all command of French, and not just your accent).

Had you been a Brit talking about yourself (but not to be used by a non-Brit towards a Brit [unless, of course, in response to a criticism of hockey or even worse, of curling] because, said in the "right" tone and context, it can be considered as very insulting) ....
.... you could have said:

je parle français comme un rosbif.

(but just as with using “comme une vache américaine/canadienne” by a North American, a Brit using “comme un rosbif” might be seen as not just talking about having a [strong] British accent, but also about having other problems with the language, such as organizing and formulating phrases and grammatical structures the way they are organized in good English and not as they should be organized in good French)

(cf: “Il parle comme un Froggy mais pense comme un Rosbif,” used at the end of the second paragraph in this recent ‘ParisBouge’ interview which, if nothing else, perhaps provides another example where the use of mutual insults like “rosbif” and “froggy” is apparently acceptable.)

(in order of their appearance, the first four links above are from/lead to:
‘en.wiktionary’;
‘fr.wiktionary’;
‘news.bbc’; and
‘projetbabel’)

Your Answer

By clicking “Post Your Answer”, you agree to our terms of service, privacy policy and cookie policy

Not the answer you're looking for? Browse other questions tagged or ask your own question.