2

The question is on words like these, with their pronunciation in IPA within brackets:

lumière [lymjɛʀ], premier [pʀəmje], boire [bwaʀ], jouet [ʒwɛ]

Question

Are the sounds [j] and [w] considered vowels or consonants?

Also, which syllabication would be correct?

(a) lu•mi•ère, pre•mi•er, bo•ire, jou•et

(b) lu•mière, pre•mier, boire, jouet

If you need context for the question of syllables: In a poem requiring twelve syllables per line how many will e.g. lumière take up?

Background

This is what I found in Littré:

lumière [lu-miè-r'], premier [pre-mié], boire [boi-r'], jouet [jou-è]

But I am not sure if the dash represents syllabification.

  • 1
    Why would [j] and [w] be considered as consonent ? A sound is considered as a vowel if you can do it without closing your mouth (with lips or tongue). Except nasal vowel, which are semi-vowels. – Random Feb 23 '16 at 8:16
  • 2
    @Random nasal vowels are plain vowels, not semi-vowels. The fact they are transcripted with a vowel/consonent combination doesn't change their phonetics. – jlliagre Feb 23 '16 at 10:13
  • @jlliagre Indeed. I'm pretty sure I remember my teacher talking about nasal vowel as a particular category... I can't remember why... Maybe because vocal cords vibrate, whereas on simple vowel they don't... (It was for speech recognition purpose...) – Random Feb 23 '16 at 10:40
  • Vocal cords usually vibrate in either cases. Nasal vowels are special because some air flow though the nose when pronouncing them, unlike oral vowels. – jlliagre Feb 23 '16 at 10:49
4

[j] and [w] are considered semivowels a.k.a. glides, in French either semi-voyelles or semi-consonnes.

In poetry, syllables would be split that way:

  • lu•mière or lu•miè•re
  • pre•mier
  • boire or boi•re
  • jou•et

Lumière and boire have one less syllable when followed by a vowel, a mute h or at the end of a verse.

Note that in poetry jouet changes its pronunciation from the monosyllabic [ʒwɛ] to to the disyllabic [ʒu.ɛ]

  • So in meter semivowels are consonants, and Littré was giving me syllabification based on the word being followed by a vowel etc. Thanks again! – Catomic Feb 24 '16 at 9:08

Your Answer

By clicking “Post Your Answer”, you agree to our terms of service, privacy policy and cookie policy

Not the answer you're looking for? Browse other questions tagged or ask your own question.