4

In one of the examples in French conditional, I found the following sentence:

Je voudrais y aller avec vous.

But I'm not sure what the y functions for. Is it true that if you omit it to just write it as Je voudrais aller avec vous., you can express the same meaning?

I hear that y works for a personal pronoun. But I'm not sure then what it stands for in this case...

6

The verb aller (when describing actual movement) requires somewhere to go to or from and that's where y comes in.

Je voudrais y aller avec vous

means I would like to go there with you.

Aller can also be used to form the future tense by meaning going to as in Je vais manger tôt - I am going to eat soon. In this case there is no movement, so y is not used.

Y is a pronoun that stands in as a dummy destination when used with aller. In English, we can just skip it.

  • Thanks. Well then does it always have to be used with y if it is used as a go verb? – Blaszard Nov 20 '16 at 19:07
  • 1
    If you don't specify any other destination (or origin), then yes. Je voudrais aller au magasin - I would like to go to the shop. Because I mentioned an actual destination, I don't need to use y. – CJ Dennis Nov 20 '16 at 23:51
3

Les deux sens ne sont pas les mêmes, avec ou sans y . y précise le verbe aller.

y aller = aller à cet endroit, dans cette pièce, au cinéma, ...

y est un pronom adverbial, représente le lieu où l'on est ou le lieu où l'on va.

Your Answer

By clicking “Post Your Answer”, you agree to our terms of service, privacy policy and cookie policy

Not the answer you're looking for? Browse other questions tagged or ask your own question.