I'm having trouble understanding the construct of this sentence.
"Pourquoi l'ont-ils construite aussi grande ?"
How is it different in meaning from this?
"Pourquoi ont-ils construit une aussi grande ville ?"
French Language Stack Exchange is a question and answer site for students, teachers, and linguists wanting to discuss the finer points of the French language. It only takes a minute to sign up.
Sign up to join this communityConsidering in your first sentence, l'
refers to a city, it can be rephrased to Pourquoi ont-ils construit cette ville aussi grande ?
. l'
is a pronoun that replaces the noun city
.
The difference in meaning with the second sentence is very tiny.
Depending on the context, there might be a nuance, the second one might be a more general question, sort of Is it useful to build such a big city, in general?
, while the first one might be more specific, sort of Is it useful for this city in particular to be so big?
. But I bet in most cases, both sentences will be actually equivalent.
Note: the question is not specific to French language, actually. The same one would apply in English between Why did they build it so big?
/ Why did they build this city so big?
and Why did they build such a big city?
adjectif attribut du complément d'objet direct (COD)
and when the COD (complement, here ville
) is replaced by a pronoun, the adjectif gets separated from its qualified name. Other examples : Je trouve ce site utile
=> Je le trouve utile
.