1

enter image description here

Ok I thought I was doing pretty good with French but it's things like this that make me sigh...

Same screen, same word in English, 3 different related words in French. Can you please explain exactly why each variation is used? I'm sure it's partly gender, but French only has 2 genders...

3

If the next word is FĂ©minin, like "conversation", we use Nouvelle.

If the next word is Masculin like "SMS", but starts with a consonant, we use Nouveau.

If the next word is Masculin like "Appel", but starts with a vowel, we use Nouvel

| improve this answer | |
  • 1
    Actually, this is a very interesting case: un nouveau SMS or un nouvel SMS ? Either you consider SMS starts with a consonant letter and it should be then nouveau, or you consider it starts with a vowel sound, and then it is nouvel. My own feeling is that both are correct, I can't find a clear grammar rule on such cases, and I have found occurences of both. – Greg Jun 24 '19 at 6:45
  • 1
    @sumelic: ... and I have found many examples of "un nouvel AR" (with AR in the sense of "arrêté royal"). I really can't make up my mind if there is a valid rule for these cases, and if it should just play "by ear" and leave it to whatever "sounds" better in terms of euphony. See eg agoria.be/WWW.wsc/rep/prg/… – Greg Jun 24 '19 at 7:19
  • 1
    @suiiurisesse: gotcha ! SMS n'est pas un acronyme : ) – Greg Jun 24 '19 at 8:16
  • 3
    @sumelic While individual letter names do usually block sandhi, initialisms behave a bit differently, usually blocking sandhi when they start with a consonant letter even if they phonologically begin with a vowel (le SPF, la SA, le FN, le MMS), but allowing sandhi if they begin with both a vowel character and actual vowel (l'OMS, les[z]USA, l'UEFA). While the usage has obviously been influenced by the spelling, it seems well established. There's some minor variations (hence your finding of some "le nouveau AR"), but as you'll notice "le nouvel AR" gets a lot more google hits. – Eau qui dort Jun 24 '19 at 10:37
  • 2
    This makes sense to me now. I was not thinking that "SMS" begins with a consonant letter. I would think the sound would dominate. In English we order "a CAT scan" but we order "an X-ray". Even better example would be when diving in water we use "a SCUBA system" (always pronouncing SCUBA as a word) but in firefighting we use "an SCBA" system". And certainly we always send "an SMS". – BetterSense Jun 24 '19 at 19:13

Not the answer you're looking for? Browse other questions tagged or ask your own question.