0

I've come across with the following sentence:

J'ai peur que vous ne deviez y aller en personne.

I thought it meant something like "I'm afraid you shouldn't go there in person" because of the adverb "ne". However, it doesn't actually negate the sentence. Here are Google Translate outputs with and without "ne":

  • with: "I'm afraid you might have to go there in person."
  • without: "I'm afraid you have to go there in person."

Can someone explain why this happens and if there's grammar term for it or something like that?

  • @Toto That question seems to be asking about the ne … que construction, not ne explétif. I do agree though that this has probably been asked before though. – Maroon Jul 14 at 15:10
  • @Maroon Yes. That's also a good resource for my question, thanks. – AtilioA Jul 14 at 15:18
2

In grammar, this ne is called an expletive, i.e. a word "used without being needed for the meaning or syntax of a sentence."

Here are some explanations:

The ne explétif does not add any meaning – negative or otherwise – to the sentence; it’s just there to draw attention to what precedes it. It’s formal and optional, and used after certain verbs and expressions that have a negative meaning, in either sense of the word: negative as in bad (fear, warning) or negative as in negated (denial, doubt). The most important thing to remember is that the ne explétif does not negate the verb it precedes; for that, you need pas.

If you need additional documentation, look at here.

| improve this answer | |
1

To add to grouah's answer, this ne is probably a reflection of the same particle found in Latin, as Grevisse points out (Bon usage, 14th ed. §1023 H1). That particle was to be found before the object clause of verbs expressing worry or fear, which is also the most common occurrence in French (In Latin, said object clause could even be negative in its own right). Its usage is expanded to various other construction now.

| improve this answer | |

Not the answer you're looking for? Browse other questions tagged or ask your own question.